This topic asks you to judge an argument and its evidence, tell primary from secondary sources and trustworthy from biased ones, compare two texts on the same subject, and combine a passage with a table, label or schedule. Work from what the texts actually say, one claim at a time.
Claims and evidence
- A claim is a point the author wants you to accept; an argument is a claim backed by evidence.
- To find the best support for a claim, pick the detail that speaks to that exact claim, not background or a different point.
- Evidence that tests the claim, such as a result that followed a change, is stronger than people's reactions or opinions.
- A claim is weakly supported when the author gives no evidence for it, or when the text points to a different explanation.
- When an author answers an objection, look for how: by giving an example, data, or a solution that worked elsewhere.
Example
"Our library should open on Sundays. During a four-week trial last spring, more than 200 people came each Sunday. Students also tell us weekends are their only free time." Which detail best supports the claim?
Solution
The trial: more than 200 visitors on each trial Sunday shows real, measured demand. The students' comment supports the claim too, but it is general and was not measured.
Strengthen or weaken an argument
- A finding strengthens an argument if it makes the author's conclusion more likely to be true.
- A finding weakens it if it supports the other side or points to another explanation.
- Two things changing together does not prove one caused the other; if a group without the change saw the same result, the cause is in doubt.
- Results from one small group, one unit, or people's own reports may not apply everywhere; a broad conclusion from thin evidence is a hasty generalization.
- Flag unfair reasoning: attacking a person instead of the argument, offering only two choices when there are more, or blaming people's motives without proof.
Example
An author argues that a hospital's new break room made staff happier, because satisfaction scores rose 10 points this year. Which finding would most weaken this argument?
Solution
Scores at a sister hospital with no new break room also rose 10 points. That suggests something else raised the scores, so the break room may not be the cause.
Primary and secondary sources
- A primary source is firsthand: it comes from direct experience or from the time being studied.
- Examples of primary sources: diaries, eyewitness accounts, interviews, original records, survey answers, and data or notes made during a study.
- A secondary source is one step removed: it reports, summarizes, or interprets other sources.
- Examples of secondary sources: history books, review articles, and articles or films that explain events or studies afterward; textbooks and encyclopedia entries also summarize other sources (some call them tertiary), so they are never primary.
Example
A student is researching a hospital flu ward in 1918. Which is a primary source: a nurse's diary written on the ward in 1918, or a history book published in 2005?
Solution
The 1918 diary, because the nurse recorded what she saw at the time. The 2005 book is secondary because its author relied on other sources.
Judge credibility and bias
- Check who wrote it and whether that person or group has real expertise on the subject.
- Ask what the author or publisher gains; a site that sells the product it praises has a reason to slant the facts.
- Material reviewed by experts before publication, such as peer-reviewed research, is generally more reliable.
- A personal story or social media post reflects one person's experience; ask whether the poster has any expertise.
- A recent date shows only that information is current; popularity and a polished design do not show that a source is fair.
Compare two texts
- Write one line for each author: the main claim, and the author's job or background if given.
- Mark where they agree and where they split; authors who disagree overall often share some common ground.
- For "both authors would agree," test the choice against each passage separately; it must fit both.
- A detail in one text challenges an idea in the other when it makes that idea less likely to hold.
- An author's work and experience can shape what that author notices and values.
Example
Author A: "A standing desk keeps me alert all afternoon, and I recommend one to every office worker." Author B: "Standing all day made my feet ache, so I now switch between sitting and standing." Which statement would both accept?
Solution
How you work at a desk can change how you feel during the day. A choice saying everyone should stand all day fails, because Author B disagrees.
Combine a passage with a table, label or schedule
- Turn the question's condition into a number first (a 7:30 shift and a 10-minute walk mean arriving by 7:20).
- Then scan the table for the rows that meet the condition; "latest" means the last row that still works.
- Apply any change from a notice (a stop removed, a new time) before you choose.
- Find servings by dividing the amount eaten by the serving size, then multiply each label amount by that number.
- Check each limit separately: "at least" means equal to or more, and "no more than" means equal to or less.
Example
A label lists 8 crackers per serving and 180 mg of sodium per serving. A person eats 20 crackers. How much sodium is that?
Solution
Servings = 20 ÷ 8 = 2.5. Sodium = 2.5 × 180 mg = 450 mg. Multiplying 180 by 20 would treat each cracker as a full serving.
Key terms
- Claim
- A statement an author wants readers to accept as true.
- Argument
- A position supported by evidence and reasoning.
- Evidence
- Facts, data, examples, or expert statements offered to support a point.
- Primary source
- Firsthand material from direct experience or the time studied, such as a diary, interview, or original record.
- Secondary source
- Material that reports, summarizes, or interprets other sources, such as a history book or review article.
- Credibility
- How far a source can be trusted, based on the author's expertise, evidence, and motives.
- Bias
- A leaning toward one side that can make a presentation unfair or incomplete.
- Peer review
- Checking of research by experts in the field before it is published.
- Correlation
- A pattern in which two things change together; on its own it does not prove that one causes the other.
- Hasty generalization
- A broad conclusion drawn from too little evidence.
- Synthesis
- Combining ideas from two or more sources to reach a new conclusion.
- Counterargument
- An opposing view that an author raises and then answers.
Common mistakes
- Choosing background or a true detail that does not address the specific claim in the question.
- Picking a finding that supports the other side as one that strengthens the argument, or the reverse.
- Calling a textbook, encyclopedia entry, or documentary made years later a primary source.
- Judging a source by its date, popularity, or design instead of the author's expertise and what the publisher gains.
- Choosing a "both authors agree" statement that only one author would accept, or swapping the two authors' views.
- Multiplying by the number of items instead of the number of servings, or reading the next row of a schedule.
Checked against: Excelsior OWL Online Reading Center, Evaluating an Argument; Excelsior OWL Online Reading Center, Synthesizing; Purdue OWL, Evaluating Sources: General Guidelines; Purdue OWL, Evaluating Digital Sources; FDA, How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label; Purdue OWL, Toulmin Argument; Wikipedia, Primary source; Wikipedia, Secondary source; Wikipedia, Tertiary source; University of Illinois Library, Primary Sources; Wikipedia, Peer review; Wikipedia, Bias; Wikipedia, Correlation does not imply causation; Wikipedia, Faulty generalization; Wikipedia, Ad hominem; Wikipedia, False dilemma; Wikipedia, Counterargument; Wikipedia, Rebuttal