This topic covers how the Spaulding system sets the minimum processing for each device, the levels of disinfection, who regulates germicides, the strengths and hazards of common chemicals, how to monitor reusable high-level disinfectants, and what happens to an endoscope after disinfection. Classify by the tissue an item touches, then follow the product's label.
Spaulding classification
Spaulding sorts devices by the infection risk of the body site they touch. The category sets the minimum processing.
- Critical: enters sterile tissue or the bloodstream, such as surgical instruments, cardiac and urinary catheters and implants; must be sterile.
- Semicritical: touches mucous membranes or nonintact skin, such as respiratory and anesthesia equipment, laryngoscope blades, some endoscopes and cystoscopes; needs at least high-level disinfection.
- Noncritical: touches only intact skin, such as bedpans, blood pressure cuffs and crutches; needs cleaning and low-level disinfection.
- Category depends on what tissue the item contacts, not on the procedure, its material, or whether it can be steam sterilized.
- Laparoscopes and arthroscopes enter sterile tissue, so CDC says they ideally should be sterilized between patients.
- When a semicritical item is high-level disinfected, rinsing with sterile water avoids picking up organisms from tap water.
Levels of disinfection
- Sterilization destroys all microbial life, including spores.
- Chemical sterilants kill spores, but only with long contact (about 3 to 12 hours).
- High-level disinfection removes all microorganisms except small numbers of bacterial spores; it kills mycobacteria, fungi and all viruses.
- Intermediate-level disinfectants kill fungi, lipid viruses, some nonlipid viruses and vegetative bacteria, tubercle bacilli included, but not spores.
- Low-level disinfectants kill lipid viruses, most vegetative bacteria (but not tubercle bacilli), and some fungi and nonlipid viruses; spores survive.
- So the key difference between intermediate and low level is killing M. tuberculosis.
- Do not use a high-level disinfectant such as glutaraldehyde on noncritical surfaces; CDC says it is too toxic and costly for that job.
Who regulates germicides, and the label
- For critical and semicritical devices, the sterilants and high-level disinfectants in liquid form fall under FDA.
- EPA registers disinfectants for noncritical environmental surfaces; this split dates from a 1993 FDA-EPA agreement.
- OSHA covers worker safety and CDC writes guidance; neither clears or registers germicides.
- Contact time and temperature come from the product's own FDA-cleared label; they differ from product to product.
- Using an EPA-registered product in a way its label does not allow, such as a shorter contact time, breaks federal law (FIFRA) and makes the user liable for harm.
Common chemicals: uses and drawbacks
- Alcohol (70%): not sporicidal and cannot penetrate protein-rich material, so it is never used to sterilize instruments; deaths from Clostridium wound infections followed such use.
- Alcohol drawbacks: damages shellac mountings on lensed instruments, swells and hardens rubber and some plastic tubing, harms tonometer tips, and is flammable.
- Glutaraldehyde: high-level disinfectant that does not corrode metal or damage lensed instruments, rubber or plastics.
- Glutaraldehyde drawbacks: vapor and contact irritate skin, eyes, nose, mouth and lungs and can cause dermatitis and asthma; use ventilation, tight-fitting lids and nitrile or butyl rubber gloves (not natural latex) with goggles.
- Ortho-phthalaldehyde (OPA): stains proteins gray, including bare skin; gray skin means poor handling and a need for better training or PPE.
- Peracetic acid: breaks down into acetic acid, water, oxygen and hydrogen peroxide, leaves no residue, works with organic matter and kills spores even at low temperature.
- Peracetic acid drawbacks: may corrode brass, copper, bronze, galvanized iron and plain steel, and is unstable once diluted.
- Sodium hypochlorite (bleach): cheap, fast and leaves no toxic residue, but corrodes metal at high strength, is weakened by organic matter, bleaches fabric, and gives off toxic chlorine gas if mixed with ammonia or acid.
- Phenolics: EPA-registered for surfaces and noncritical devices, not FDA-cleared as high-level disinfectants, not sporicidal; never use them on occupied infant bassinets or incubators.
- Quaternary ammonium compounds: for noncritical surfaces like walls, floors and furniture, and for equipment touching intact skin; not sporicidal and generally not tuberculocidal.
Monitoring reusable high-level disinfectants
- Test the solution for minimum effective concentration (MEC) each day it is used, or more often, with the matching chemical indicator strip, and document the result.
- If the strip shows the solution is below MEC, discard it, even if its reuse life is not over.
- Never top it off, extend the soak, or finish the day's load in a failed solution.
- Never use a solution past the manufacturer's reuse life (for example, 14 days for OPA); a passing strip cannot extend it.
- Concentration drops mainly because wet instruments carry water into the basin and dilute it.
- Test strips also expire; date the bottle when opened.
Endoscopes after high-level disinfection
- Rinse the scope and flush every channel with water to remove disinfectant; retained chemical can harm the next patient, for example by causing colitis.
- Rinse water may be sterile, filtered or tap water; after a tap or filtered water rinse, flush with alcohol and dry with forced air.
- Hang scopes vertically so they dry, and store them where they are protected from damage and contamination.
- Do not store scopes in the carrying case used to ship them; a case can recontaminate a clean scope.
- Keep a log for each procedure: patient name and record number, procedure, date, endoscopist, reprocessing system (if more than one), and the scope's serial number or other identifier.
Key terms
- Critical item
- Device entering sterile tissue or the vascular system, such as a surgical instrument; must be sterile.
- Semicritical item
- Device touching mucous membranes or nonintact skin, such as a laryngoscope blade; needs at least high-level disinfection.
- Noncritical item
- Device touching only intact skin, such as a blood pressure cuff; needs low-level disinfection.
- High-level disinfection
- Process killing all microorganisms except small numbers of bacterial spores.
- Intermediate-level disinfectant
- Chemical that kills vegetative bacteria including tubercle bacilli, fungi, lipid and some nonlipid viruses, but not spores.
- Low-level disinfectant
- Chemical that kills most vegetative bacteria, lipid viruses and some fungi, but not tubercle bacilli or spores.
- Chemical sterilant
- Germicide that kills spores when given long contact, often 3 to 12 hours.
- Minimum effective concentration (MEC)
- Lowest strength at which a reusable disinfectant still meets its label claim; checked with test strips.
- Reuse life
- Maximum number of days a reusable solution may be used, set by its manufacturer, regardless of strip results.
- Glutaraldehyde
- Metal-safe high-level disinfectant whose vapor irritates airways and skin; needs ventilation and nitrile or butyl gloves.
- Ortho-phthalaldehyde (OPA)
- High-level disinfectant that stains proteins, including unprotected skin, gray.
- Peracetic acid
- Sporicidal chemical leaving no residue that can corrode copper, brass, bronze and plain steel.
- Sodium hypochlorite
- Bleach; fast and cheap but corrosive at high strength and releases chlorine gas with ammonia or acid.
- Quaternary ammonium compound
- Low-level surface disinfectant for noncritical items; not sporicidal and generally not tuberculocidal.
- FIFRA
- Federal law under which EPA registers disinfectants; using a product against its label is a violation.
- Phenolic
- EPA-registered surface disinfectant, not cleared for high-level use, kept off occupied infant bassinets.
Common mistakes
- Classify by the tissue touched, not the procedure or material: a laryngoscope blade is semicritical, a blood pressure cuff noncritical, a surgical instrument critical.
- Semicritical needs at least high-level disinfection, not intermediate or low level; noncritical needs low-level disinfection, not a high-level chemical and not nothing.
- High-level disinfection spares only small numbers of spores, not mycobacteria or nonenveloped viruses. Killing tubercle bacilli is what separates intermediate from low level, and only sterilants kill spores.
- Match the drawback to the chemical: glutaraldehyde irritates airways but does not corrode metal; OPA stains skin gray; alcohol damages lens mountings and rubber and is flammable; bleach releases chlorine gas with ammonia or acid; peracetic acid leaves no residue but corrodes some metals.
- Follow the label for contact time: never shorten it, double it on a hunch, or use a coworker's time. Test MEC daily, discard a failed solution, and never use a passing strip to go beyond the reuse life.
- FDA, not EPA, OSHA or CDC, regulates high-level disinfectants for devices. After disinfection, rinse scopes thoroughly, hang them vertically to dry, and never store them damp, capped or in the shipping case.
Checked against: CDC, Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008, updated 2024), print version