This topic covers the three kinds of sterilization monitoring (physical, chemical, biological), the daily Bowie-Dick test, testing after a sterilizer is installed, moved or repaired, what to do when a test fails, and the labels and records that make a recall possible. For each monitor, know what it proves and what it does not.
Three kinds of monitoring
- Physical (mechanical) monitors: the printout, graph or display of time, temperature and pressure for each cycle.
- Chemical indicators (CIs): inks that change color when exposed to one or more process conditions, placed on and inside packs.
- Biological indicators (BIs): resistant bacterial spores; only a BI directly measures whether the process killed organisms.
- At the end of each cycle, the operator reviews the printout, confirms the exposure time, temperature and pressure were met, checks that the cycle number matches the load label, and initials it.
- If the printout or any CI suggests poor processing, do not release the load: treat it as not sterile, reprocess it and report the failure.
- No item from that load is released, implant or not, and a later BI result does not rescue it.
Chemical indicators
- An external indicator (such as indicator tape) shows only that the package went through a process; it does not prove the contents are sterile.
- An internal indicator, placed inside each pack, shows the sterilant got through to the inside.
- If the internal indicator can be seen through the package, as in a clear peel pouch, CDC says an external one is not needed; the internal one is still required.
- CIs do not replace BIs; they can show a pass at cycle times too short to sterilize.
- ISO 11140 sorts CIs into six types, by intended use rather than rank.
- Type 1, process indicator: tape or labels on the outside that separate processed from unprocessed items.
- Type 2, specific-test indicator: for a particular test, such as the Bowie-Dick air-removal test.
- Type 3 reacts to one critical variable; Type 4 (multi-variable) reacts to two or more.
- Type 5, integrating indicator: reacts to all critical variables and is built to equal or exceed BI performance requirements.
- Type 6, emulating indicator: reacts to all critical variables but is matched to specific cycles, so use it only in the cycle on its label.
- CDC's 2008 text uses AAMI's older five classes, with similar names for the first five.
Bowie-Dick and leak tests
- The Bowie-Dick test checks air removal and detects air leaks in dynamic-air-removal (prevacuum) steam sterilizers; it is not a sterility test.
- Gravity steam units, EtO and hydrogen peroxide sterilizers do not use it.
- Run it each day the sterilizer is used, before the first load, in an otherwise empty chamber.
- Lay the test pack flat on the lowest front part of the rack, close to the door, above the drain; CDC describes a 3.5-minute exposure at 134°C.
- Pass: a uniform color change across the whole sheet.
- Fail: a lighter spot anywhere on the sheet means trapped air kept steam from reaching that area.
- After a failure, the sterilizer stays out of use until maintenance inspects it and it passes a Bowie-Dick test; adding exposure time does not fix it.
- The vacuum leak test is a separate routine test of the chamber; run it as the sterilizer IFU specifies, and do not treat the Bowie-Dick as a substitute.
Biological indicators
- Steam: Geobacillus stearothermophilus spores, incubated at 55 to 60°C.
- EtO and dry heat: Bacillus atrophaeus spores, incubated at 35 to 37°C.
- CDC's Sterilizing Practices chapter also lists G. stearothermophilus for peroxide gas plasma and for liquid peracetic acid systems; always use the BI the sterilizer maker specifies.
- Monitor steam and low-temperature sterilizers with BIs at least weekly, and preferably daily for sterilizers that run several loads a day.
- Put a BI in every load that contains an implant, and hold the implant until the BI is negative whenever possible.
- Also incubate a control BI from the same lot that never went through the cycle, to prove the spores were alive and the media could grow them.
- If the control shows no growth, the test BI's negative result means nothing; repeat the test with a good lot.
- A process challenge device (PCD) is a test pack or tray built to challenge the process; it contains a BI, an enzyme-only indicator or a Type 5 integrator.
- For routine steam monitoring, lay the BI test pack flat in a fully loaded chamber at the hardest-to-sterilize spot, usually the front bottom near the drain.
After installation, relocation, major repair or a failure
- Run three consecutive empty cycles with a BI and CI in a test pack, testing each cycle type separately.
- Prevacuum units also need three consecutive empty-chamber Bowie-Dick tests.
- Return the sterilizer to service only when all BIs are negative and all CIs reach their correct end point.
Positive BIs and recalls
- Steam, first step: take the sterilizer out of service and notify the supervisor and infection control.
- Then repeat the BI in three consecutive cycles as soon as possible, and check the settings, steam supply and that the right BI was used and read correctly.
- One positive steam BI does not by itself force recall of nonimplant items; recall them if maintenance finds a malfunction or wrong settings, or if repeat BIs stay positive.
- Once a malfunction is found, items from the suspect loads are treated as nonsterile, recalled as far as possible and reprocessed.
- Other methods (EtO, hydrogen peroxide): treat one positive BI as a failure; everything processed from the cycle with the last negative BI to the next good BI is nonsterile and is retrieved if possible.
- If policy allows an implant to be used before its BI result in an emergency, release it only as a documented exception: record the load ID, the patient's name or hospital ID and the BI result.
Labels and records
- Label each sterilized item with the sterilizer, the cycle or load number, the sterilization date and, if used, the expiration date.
- For each cycle, record the sterilizer and cycle type, load ID, load contents, exposure parameters, operator's name or initials, and all physical, chemical and biological results.
- Keep sterilization records for the period required by standards (CDC gives 3 years as an example), by statutes of limitations, and by state and federal law.
Key terms
- Physical monitor
- Printout, graph or display showing a cycle's time, temperature and pressure; also called mechanical monitoring.
- External chemical indicator
- Indicator on a package's outside showing only that it was exposed to a sterilization process.
- Internal chemical indicator
- Indicator placed inside a package to show sterilant reached the contents.
- Process indicator
- ISO Type 1 marker, such as tape, separating processed from unprocessed packages.
- Integrating indicator
- ISO Type 5 device reacting to all critical variables, designed to perform at or beyond BI requirements.
- Emulating indicator
- ISO Type 6 device reacting to all critical variables, matched to the specific cycle on its label.
- Bowie-Dick test
- Daily empty-chamber air-removal check for prevacuum steam sterilizers, run before the first load.
- Leak test
- Vacuum check of whether a prevacuum chamber is airtight, run on the sterilizer maker's schedule.
- Biological indicator (BI)
- Carrier of resistant spores that shows whether a cycle actually killed organisms.
- Geobacillus stearothermophilus
- Spore-former used to monitor steam (and per CDC peroxide plasma and peracetic acid); incubated at 55-60°C.
- Bacillus atrophaeus
- Spore-former used to monitor EtO and dry heat; incubated at 35-37°C.
- Control BI
- Unprocessed indicator from the same lot, incubated to prove the spores could grow.
- Process challenge device (PCD)
- Test pack or tray that challenges the cycle and holds a BI, integrating indicator or enzyme-only indicator.
- Quarantine
- Holding processed items, such as implants, until monitoring results allow release.
- Recall
- Retrieving items from suspect loads so they can be reprocessed and patient exposure assessed.
- Load label
- Package marking naming the sterilizer, cycle or load number, date and any expiration, enabling tracing.
Common mistakes
- Treating a color-changed external indicator as proof of sterility, or releasing a load whose printout shows a missed temperature. External CIs show exposure only; a failed physical or chemical result rejects the whole load.
- Mixing up the ISO types: tape is Type 1, the Bowie-Dick sheet is Type 2, Type 5 integrates all variables to BI level, and Type 6 is valid only in the cycle it is labeled for.
- Running the Bowie-Dick weekly, in a full load, on gravity or low-temperature units, or passing a sheet with a lighter center spot. It is daily, empty chamber, prevacuum only, and any spot is a fail.
- Swapping BI organisms and temperatures: G. stearothermophilus for steam at 55-60°C, B. atrophaeus for EtO and dry heat at 35-37°C. A weekly BI or an integrator does not cover an implant load.
- Reading a negative test BI as a pass when its control did not grow; the result is invalid and the test is repeated.
- Confusing recall rules: steam means out of service, notify, and retest, with recall when a malfunction is found; EtO or peroxide means everything since the last negative BI is nonsterile. Re-incubating the BI or ignoring it is never the answer.
Checked against: CDC, Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008): Sterilizing Practices; CDC, Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008): Steam Sterilization; CDC, Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008): Flash Sterilization; CDC, Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008), full PDF (recommendations, glossary, Table 12); WHO/PAHO, Decontamination and Reprocessing of Medical Devices for Health-care Facilities (2016)